Top 10 Cities Where Home Sellers Are Taking Huge Losses – San Francisco Leads with 20% Plunge, Four Times the National Average

Famous Painted Ladies of San Francisco, California, USA

In San Francisco, a significant number of home sellers are facing financial losses at levels not seen in over a decade, primarily due to home prices normalizing after a period of steep increases. Currently, nearly 20% of sellers in the city are selling their homes for less than their purchase price, with average losses around $155,500.

In contrast, the national picture is less grim, with only 4% of home sellers across the United States facing losses, as home prices generally continue to hover near peak levels. The typical loss for these sellers is about $40,000.

Redfin conducted an analysis of the top 50 metros to identify the cities where sellers are taking the biggest hits. Here are the top 10 cities where home sellers are facing significant losses.

San Francisco, CA

San Francisco downtown skyline Aerial view at sunset from Ina Coolbrith Park Hill in San Francisco, California, USA.
Depositphotos Photo by vichie81

San Francisco, renowned for its iconic Golden Gate Bridge, steep rolling hills, and eclectic mix of architecture, faces a challenging real estate market. As of recent data, nearly 18% of home sellers in San Francisco experience losses, with the median loss reaching a staggering $155,500. This rate is significantly higher than the national average. Despite its vibrant culture and booming tech industry, San Francisco’s real estate market shows that high demand does not always equate to profitable sales.

Detroit, MI

Detroit, Michigan, USA downtown skyline from above at dusk.
Depositphotos Photo by sepavone

Detroit, known as the birthplace of Motown and the U.S. auto industry, is experiencing a mixed real estate scenario. While the city has been undergoing revitalization efforts, about 10.8% of home sellers still end up selling at a loss, with a median financial setback of $16,812. This reflects the ongoing challenges and disparities in economic recovery across different neighborhoods, despite Detroit’s rich cultural heritage and efforts to boost local industry and housing.

Cleveland, OH

Cleveland, Ohio, USA downtown city skyline on the Cuyahoga River at twilight.
Depositphotos Photo by sepavone

Cleveland, situated on the shores of Lake Erie, is known for its rich musical history, including the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. However, the housing market here sees 8.2% of its home sales occurring at a loss, with sellers facing a median loss of $20,765. The city’s market reflects a broader struggle in the Rust Belt, where economic shifts continue to impact real estate values unevenly across the region.

St. Louis, MO

St. Louis, Missouri, USA downtown cityscape with the arch and courthouse at dusk.
Depositphotos Photo by sepavone

St. Louis, home to the iconic Gateway Arch, blues music, and vibrant cultural scenes, shows a real estate market where 8.1% of sellers take losses, averaging a median of $18,500. This statistic highlights the challenges within a transitioning market that is still grappling with economic disparities and shifting industrial landscapes.

Chicago, IL

Downtown Chicago, Illinois
Depositphotos Photo by lmel900

Chicago, a bustling metropolis known for its impressive skyline, deep-dish pizza, and rich history, faces its share of real estate challenges. Approximately 7.9% of home sales result in losses, with the median loss pegged at $30,000. Despite its economic diversity and cultural attractions, Chicago’s real estate market varies widely by neighborhood, influencing overall profitability for sellers.

Pittsburgh, PA

Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA skyline on the river.
Depositphotos Photo by sepavone

Pittsburgh, once the steel capital of the world, now thrives on healthcare, education, and technology. Yet, 7.3% of its home sales end in losses, with sellers seeing a median loss of $15,000. This reflects the uneven economic development and the transformation of its housing market amidst shifting industrial foundations.

New York, NY

Times Square New York
Depositphotos Photo by IgorVetushko

New York City, a global hub of finance, culture, and entertainment, is not immune to real estate downturns. In this high-stakes market, 6.9% of sellers suffer losses, with a significant median loss of $97,723. The city’s vast economic disparities and the premium on space make the real estate market particularly volatile for sellers.

Baltimore, MD

Baltimore, Maryland, USA cityscape at Mt. Vernon and the Washington Monument.
Depositphotos Photo by sepavone

Baltimore, known for its historic Inner Harbor, vibrant arts scene, and unique neighborhoods, sees 6.1% of home sales conclude at a loss, with a median loss of $27,000. Baltimore’s real estate market reflects its ongoing urban revitalization efforts, which have yet to uniformly raise property values across all areas.

Milwaukee, WI

Milwaukee, WIsconsin, USA downtown skyline at dusk.
Depositphotos Photo by sepavone

Milwaukee, famous for its breweries and the Milwaukee Art Museum, also faces challenges in its housing market. Here, 6.1% of homes are sold at a loss, with a median loss value of $18,000. The city’s economic transitions, from manufacturing to service industries, impact its real estate values and profitability for sellers.

Austin, TX

Austin, Texas, USA downtown skyline.
Depositphotos Photo by sepavone

Austin, a vibrant city known for its live music, tech industry, and outdoor activities, has a relatively high percentage of home sales at a loss compared to its overall growth story, with 6% of sales ending in the red and a median loss of $45,000. This illustrates the volatility that can accompany rapid growth and rising property values, challenging some homeowners when it’s time to sell.

New England and Southern California Faring Better

Providence, Rhode Island
Depositphotos Photo by sepavone

Homes in Providence, RI, were least likely to sell at a loss, with only 1.2% of homeowners seeing red during the three months ending February 29. Close behind were Boston, Anaheim, CA, Fort Lauderdale, FL, and San Diego, where approximately 2% of homes sold below their purchase prices.

In terms of financial impact, the smallest losses occurred in cities where housing costs are relatively low. Pittsburgh and Kansas City, MO, led with median losses of $15,000, followed by Detroit with $16,812, Houston with $16,990, and Milwaukee with $18,000. These figures reflect the regions where economic losses, when they occur, tend to be less severe.

Not All Gloom And Doom

Happy Senior couple sitting at table with calculator and counting money
Depositphotos Photo by AndrewLozovyi

The overwhelming majority of sellers are profiting from their home sales. Even in San Francisco, despite approximately 18% of sellers taking losses, a strong 82% are selling their homes for more than their initial purchase price. The average seller in San Francisco enjoyed a gain of $482,000 over the purchase price in the three months ending February 29 as per the Redfin report.

Across the nation, around 96% of sellers are seeing gains, with the median profit standing at $196,016. The likelihood of selling a home for more than its purchase price remains high, as the median U.S. home-sale price is only 5% below the peak reached in mid-2022 and has risen over 40% since 2019.

In California, home sellers generally see larger profits than those in other parts of the country. Following San Francisco, San Jose saw the next highest median gain where only 5% of sellers suffered losses and 95% profited, with gains averaging $695,000. In Anaheim, where just 2% of transactions were at a loss, the median gain was $510,000.

Affordable Regions Have Smaller Gains

Columbus, Ohio, USA skyline and park.
Depositphotos Photo by sepavone

Conversely, the smallest profits are often in the more affordable Rust Belt metros, although median gains are approaching six figures. The lowest median gain was in Cleveland, OH, where sellers netted an average of $70,650—a significant portion of the $175,000 median sale price. This is followed by Detroit, with a median gain of $72,000, and St. Louis, at $90,000.

Like Financial Freedom Countdown content? Be sure to follow us!


The 10 States Taxing Social Security in 2024 and the 2 That Just Stopped

USA social security card with medicare and US dollars
Depositphotos Photo by steveheap

As 2023 tax filing season draws to a close, retirees across the nation are adjusting their financial plans for 2024, but a crucial detail could drastically alter the landscape of retirement living: the taxing of Social Security benefits. While many bask in the belief that their golden years will be tax-friendly, residents in nine specific states are facing a reality check as their Social Security benefits come under the taxman’s purview. Conversely, a wave of relief is set to wash over two states, marking an end to their era of taxing these benefits. This shift paints a complex portrait of retirement planning across the U.S., underscoring the importance of staying informed of the ever changing tax laws. Are you residing in one of these states? It’s time to uncover the impact of these tax changes on your retirement strategy and possibly reconsider your locale choice for those serene post-work years. Here are the states taxing social security benefits.

The States Taxing Social Security in 2024 and the 2 That Just Stopped

Shift From Employee to Investor Mindset with the Cashflow Quadrant Methodology by Robert Kiyosaki

Someone reading the iconic book Rich dad and Poor Dad
Depositphotos Photo by ifeelstock

Countless systems have been established that provide a much better understanding of what income generation is, how it can be used, and how individuals can organize their financial life as they work towards financial freedom. One of the more successful and better-known examples of financial education is the Cashflow Quadrant, the book by Robert Kiyosaki. Rich Dad’s Cashflow Quadrant was revolutionary for the way it organized money and helped people better learn how to increase their income. As the name implies, there are four quadrants within the Cashflow Quadrant. By mastering each of the four categories – or specializing in one – a person can increase their revenue stream and ultimately make more money.

Shift From Employee to Investor Mindset with the Cashflow Quadrant Methodology by Robert Kiyosaki

Retire Abroad and Still Collect Social Security? Avoid These 9 Countries Where It’s Not Possible

Social security benefits
Depositphotos Photo by gunnar3000

Dreaming of retiring to a sun-drenched beach or a quaint village? Many Americans envision spending their golden years abroad, savoring the delights of new cultures and landscapes. However, an essential part of this dream hinges on the financial stability provided by Social Security benefits. Before packing your bags and bidding farewell, it’s crucial to know that not all countries play by the same rules when it comes to collecting these benefits overseas. Here are the nine countries where your dream of retiring abroad could hit a snag, as Social Security benefits don’t cross every border. Avoid living in these countries so your retirement plans don’t get lost in translation.

Retire Abroad and Still Collect Social Security? Avoid These 9 Countries Where It’s Not Possible

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *